Beyond the Garden
Past Due
A dead novelist leaves his best friend an unfinished manuscript—and a final request to finish it. The pages take something from the writer, but readers may be paying the real cost.
William Franklin had been dead for nineteen days when his wife brought Elias Graham the box.
It was an ordinary banker’s box with WILLIAM’S NOTES written across the lid in black marker, and there was no ceremony to it—no ribbon, no legal envelope, no solemn instruction from an attorney. Mara Franklin carried it into Elias’s office at the university, set it on top of a stack of student manuscripts, and said, “He wanted you to have these.”
Elias looked at the box. “What are they?”
“You know as much as I do.”
That was probably true. William had spent thirty years writing novels and guarding unfinished work as though it were evidence in a murder trial. Mara sat across from Elias’s desk and folded her hands in her lap. The exhaustion in her face bothered Elias more than he expected. He remembered the first week after the funeral, when someone had always been at the house with food or flowers or something useful to say, and wondered what the place felt like now that everyone had gone back to work.
“There’s a note in there for you,” she said. “He wrote it a couple of months ago. At least I think he did. I found it with the rest.”
“Did you read it?”
“No.” She gave him a tired smile when he looked surprised. “He wrote your name on it.”
Elias nodded. William would have appreciated that.
Mara stood and rested one hand on the box. “You were his best friend.”
Elias almost corrected her. Had been, maybe. Twenty years earlier they had talked every day and spent entire nights in cheap apartments arguing about Raymond Carver and Stephen King and whether there was such a thing as a sentence that could not be improved. Then William published The Orchard Road, followed by Winter County, and The Summer We Left spent months on the bestseller list. Elias published two novels that received kind reviews and indifferent sales. After that came teaching, then tenure, then the peculiar purgatory of being introduced at faculty dinners as “novelist Elias Graham” when he hadn’t finished a novel in eleven years.
They were still friends, but success had changed the geometry of the friendship. William had kept moving. Elias had become somebody who taught other people how to move.
“He really did love you, you know,” Mara said.
“I know.”
After she left, Elias waited until the office door clicked shut before opening the box. Inside were eleven notebooks, three legal pads, a folder of printed pages, and an envelope with ELIAS written across the front in William’s narrow handwriting.
He opened it.
E—
If you’re reading this, either I finally learned how to organize my office or something has gone wrong.
Probably the second one.
There’s a manuscript in the blue notebook. It’s the best thing I’ve ever written. I know how that sounds. I’ve said that before. This time I mean it.
It’s also taken more out of me than anything I’ve ever worked on. Literally, some days it feels like.
I don’t know if I’ll finish it. If I don’t, I want you to.
Not Mara. Not the publisher. You.
You know where I cheat. You know when I’m trying too hard. You know which parts I’d cut even after spending three months defending them.
Finish it. If it becomes a book, put both our names on it.
And don’t let the damn thing disappear.
—W
Elias read the letter twice, then found the blue notebook beneath two legal pads. The first page contained only a title written across the top: PAST DUE. Underneath it, William had added Maybe.
Elias smiled. That was William too—commit to nothing until the jacket copy was approved.
He started reading and lost track of time almost immediately.
William’s prose had always been clean, but this was different. There was no showing off in it. The pages seemed almost indifferent to being admired, which only made them harder to put down.
One passage made Elias stop:
By morning the house had returned to itself. The chairs were where they belonged. The windows were latched. Nothing was missing except whatever had been in the white bowl on the kitchen table.
They stood around it after breakfast, each waiting for someone else to remember.
No one did.
By noon, they had begun arguing over who had emptied it.
Elias read the passage again. He could already hear William dismissing one of the sentences as too obvious, then defending it for three months.
An hour later, someone knocked on his office door. Elias ignored it until they knocked again.
“Come in.”
A student opened the door halfway. “Professor Graham? Workshop?”
Elias looked at the clock and realized he was twenty-three minutes late. “Sorry. I lost track of time.”
The student smiled. “That’s new.”
“Don’t get used to it.”
He closed the notebook and followed the student into the hall, still thinking about William’s pages. The bastard had been right. It was the best thing he had ever written.
Elias waited six days before adding anything. He told himself it was respect, though fear had more to do with it.
William had stopped in the middle of a conversation between two characters sitting in a kitchen at three in the morning. Nothing extraordinary was happening. They were simply talking when one of them asked:
How long do you think a person can owe something before it stops being a debt?
And that was where William had stopped.
Elias read the last ten pages enough times that he could almost recite them. Late on a Thursday night, he opened a new document on his laptop, copied the final paragraph, and placed his cursor beneath it. For twenty minutes, he did nothing.
Then he wrote:
Until somebody comes to collect.
He stared at the sentence. William would have hated it. Too neat.
Elias deleted it and tried again.
Two hours later, he had written four paragraphs. Four paragraphs, and they were better than anything Elias had written in years. He knew that with the kind of certainty writers were not supposed to admit possessing.
On the third rereading, he noticed his hands were trembling. When he leaned back, the room tilted slightly. He hadn’t eaten dinner. That had to be it.
He stood and nearly fell against the desk.
The next morning he woke at eleven with a headache behind his eyes and an ache in his joints that reminded him of the flu. He was fifty-three and felt much older. By Monday he felt normal again, so he wrote six more paragraphs.
Tuesday was worse.
Dr. Samuel Pike taught twentieth-century literature two offices down from Elias and had spent fifteen years asking when Elias planned to stop pretending he preferred teaching to writing. Elias trusted Sam because Sam had read both of his published novels before publication and had disliked large portions of each.
He emailed him sixty-five pages—William’s manuscript followed by Elias’s additions—and did not say where one writer stopped and the other began. The subject line said:
Tell me if I’m insane.
Sam called that evening.
“You’re insane.”
Elias closed his eyes. “I knew it.”
“No. You’re insane if you don’t finish this.”
Elias opened them. “You’re serious?”
“Who wrote it?”
“William started it.”
There was a pause. “Started?”
“I’ve been continuing it.”
Another pause, longer this time. “That last scene is yours?”
“Most of it.”
“Elias.”
“What?”
“You need to finish this.”
Elias laughed. He had been waiting eleven years for someone to say that and mean it without qualification.
Sam kept talking. “I know someone at Bell & Wren. Let me send it to her.”
“No.”
“Why?”
“Because it’s sixty-five pages.”
“It’s sixty-five pages better than ninety percent of what gets submitted.”
“William’s name complicates things.”
“William wanted you to finish it, right?”
Elias looked at the letter beside his keyboard. “Yes.”
“Then let me make a phone call.”
“Let me think about it.”
“Think fast.”
They hung up. Several minutes passed before Elias noticed the headache was gone. By the following morning, so was the ache in his knees.
Sam sent the manuscript anyway.
Elias was furious for approximately nine minutes.
Then the editor called.
Her name was Rebecca Lane.
“I thought William had abandoned this,” she said.
Elias sat up straighter. “You knew about it?”
“He sent me the first sixty-one pages months ago. What Sam sent me includes those pages and goes past where William stopped.”
“So you’d read most of it before.”
“William’s part, yes. I hadn’t seen yours.”
“And?”
“It’s better.”
Elias said nothing.
“I read Sam’s packet twice,” Rebecca continued. “Then I sent it to acquisitions.”
“How many people?”
“Three so far.”
Elias got up from his kitchen table without bracing a hand against anything. For the past two weeks, standing had required the small unconscious negotiation people began making with their bodies once age stopped being theoretical. This time it simply happened.
Rebecca kept talking. Bell & Wren wanted a meeting.
When the call ended, Elias went to the bathroom and studied himself in the mirror. He looked rested. The excitement was good for him, he decided. He had been sleeping better.
Bell & Wren offered him an advance eleven days later, enough for him to take leave from the university and find out whether he could actually finish the book.
Elias signed.
A week later, Sam stopped Elias in the hallway outside the department office and handed him a paper cup.
“Coffee.”
Elias looked at it. “What did I do?”
“You look like hell.”
“That’s rich.”
Sam took a sip from his own cup. “I’ve earned it. You’re still pretending you haven’t.”
They stood there for a minute while students moved around them toward afternoon classes.
Sam nodded toward the stack of papers under Elias’s arm. “You teaching tonight?”
“Workshop.”
“Tell them all their dialogue is too long.”
“Yours is.”
“Mine is literature.”
Elias laughed.
Sam pointed at him with the coffee cup. “There. Better.”
Then he headed back toward his office.
The contract required pages every four weeks. Rebecca joked that it was because William Franklin was dead and Elias Graham had not published anything since people still bought DVDs. Elias appreciated the honesty.
He wrote thirty-one pages the first month. By page twenty, he had developed persistent nausea. By page twenty-five, his hands shook when he held a coffee cup. At thirty-one, he called his doctor.
Blood tests showed nothing dramatic: mild anemia, inflammatory markers slightly elevated, nothing that explained why climbing the stairs to his bedroom left him breathing hard. His doctor suggested sleep, hydration, less caffeine, and fewer hours sitting at a desk.
Elias sent the pages to Rebecca on a Wednesday. She called them extraordinary the next day. By Friday, marketing had seen them too.
Saturday morning, Elias walked three miles. He hadn’t set out to exercise. He simply kept going.
On Sunday, he ignored the manuscript and went through William’s other notebooks.
Most contained what he expected: character names, scraps of dialogue, lists of things William thought he might use someday. Halfway through a black notebook dated the previous year, Elias found an entry that made him stop.
March 12 — 1,840 words. Awful afterward. Slept 13 hrs.
Several pages later:
March 28 — Mara read opening. Better today. Probably coincidence.
Then:
April 4 — Rebecca read through p. 61. Woke hungry. First time in weeks.
Elias read that one twice. Rebecca. Now her phone call made sense.
He continued.
April 11 — Worse again. Should stop. Scene won’t leave me alone.
April 19 — No writing for 6 days. Better. Need to stop for a while.
April 21 — Couldn’t.
Elias closed the notebook and left his hands resting on the cover. Until then he had been frightened mostly by what the work was doing to his body. William’s entries made the fear harder to contain.
He hated thinking of what came next as an experiment, but that was what it was.
For several days Elias tried to reduce the improvement to ordinary causes. He was working again. He was eating. People whose judgment he respected were telling him the pages were good.
That had to count for something.
He wrote three pages and felt bad enough the next afternoon to cancel class. They were weak, and he knew it before he printed them. That was partly why he chose them.
He drove to Sam’s house.
“Read these.”
Sam took them. “Now?”
“Yes.”
“You drove over here because you wanted me to—”
“Please.”
Sam gave him a long look, then sat down.
By the second page, Sam was frowning.
Something in Elias’s chest loosened.
The tremor in his fingers faded before Sam finished the third.
Sam lowered the pages. “These aren’t as good.”
Elias held out his hand and watched it remain steady.
“No,” he said. “They’re not.”
Sam began explaining where the scene had gone wrong. Elias caught only pieces of it.
Over the next few weeks the pattern became difficult to dismiss. Rebecca read pages. Publicity read pages. Copyediting read pages. An assistant Elias had never met emailed to tell him she had cried at a particular scene. Whenever the manuscript traveled farther than his desk, he seemed to recover.
Sam looked worse the next time Elias saw him.
They met for lunch at a diner near campus, and Elias noticed the change before Sam reached the table. His shoulders seemed lower than they had a month earlier, and dark crescents had appeared beneath his eyes.
“You look terrible,” Elias said.
“Thank you.”
“You sleeping?”
“End of semester.”
Sam waved down the waitress and ordered coffee. Halfway through telling Elias about a faculty meeting, he stopped and frowned.
“What was I saying?”
“Budget committee.”
“Right.”
He picked the story back up. Elias tried to follow it.
The new pages were in his bag—twenty-two of them. He had intended to hand them over as soon as Sam sat down, but they stayed beside his chair until the check arrived.
When Elias finally slid the envelope across the table, Sam brightened. “You’ve been holding out on me.”
“They’re rough.”
“That has never stopped you before.”
Sam tucked the pages under his arm.
For a moment Elias considered taking them back.
“Let me know what you think,” he said.
Two days later Sam called.
“You son of a bitch.”
“That bad?”
“That good.”
The exhaustion in Sam’s voice was obvious now.
“You okay?”
“Fine.”
“You sure?”
“I stayed up too late reading your stupid book.”
Elias smiled automatically.
Then Sam said, “These pages take it out of me.”
The smile left.
After a silence, Sam asked, “You there?”
“Yeah.”
Elias looked at the manuscript on his desk.
“Twelve more when you want them.”
Sam laughed. “Of course there are.”
Elias sent them the next morning.
Rebecca had begun looking tired too.
During a video call Elias noticed her hair pulled back carelessly and the washed-out skin beneath her eyes.
“Did you get the new chapter?” he asked.
“Read it last night.”
She opened a folder, then frowned.
“What?”
“Nothing. I wrote down a question and now I can’t remember why.” She studied the note for another second. “Apparently forty-six is when the machinery starts failing.”
Elias gave a small laugh.
He let the subject change.
Sam died in October.
He was fifty-eight.
The official cause was cardiac arrest. There was nothing extraordinary about that, medically speaking. People had heart attacks every day. Elias repeated versions of this to himself during the funeral until the sentences lost their meaning.
He stood beside Sam’s wife afterward while people moved through the reception hall carrying paper plates of food they did not want.
“He’d been dragging lately,” she said. “I thought it was work. He always blamed work.”
“How long?”
She looked toward the sanctuary. “I don’t know. Long enough that I should’ve made more of it.”
Sam had read every page Elias sent him. Every revision, every alternate ending, every scene Elias hated and wanted someone else to tell him was good.
“He was so excited about your book,” she said.
Elias closed his eyes.
He stopped writing.
For a while, it was easier than he expected. He ignored Rebecca’s calls, told his agent the manuscript was delayed, went back to campus and sat through department meetings and pretended to care about enrollment targets. The manuscript remained closed on his desk at one hundred eighty-four pages, perhaps seventy from completion.
His health stabilized, but the strength returned by readers thinned gradually. The stairs felt longer. His hands ached again in the mornings. One afternoon he found himself resting halfway across campus without remembering when he had decided to stop.
Then he started thinking about the kitchen scene.
This time it wasn’t William’s. It was his own.
A woman had opened a drawer and found something Elias had not yet decided how to describe. The scene followed him through brushing his teeth, grading papers, standing in line at the pharmacy. Sentences kept suggesting themselves. Most were bad until one arrived that wasn’t.
He wrote it on the back of a receipt, stared at it for a long time, then threw it away.
That night he dug it back out of the trash.
Three days later he opened the manuscript.
“I’m just reading,” he said aloud.
Eleven pages later, he fixed a sentence. Then another. At 2:14 a.m., he looked up and discovered he had written nine new pages.
The next morning his hands shook badly enough that coffee ran down the cabinet doors. He was wiping it from the floor when his phone began ringing.
Rebecca.
He let it go.
She called again that afternoon.
“I have an idea,” she said.
Elias waited.
“We release an excerpt.”
“No.”
“You haven’t even heard the pitch.”
“No.”
“William Franklin’s final novel, completed by his closest friend. We release the first three chapters with every preorder. Fifteen, twenty pages up front, enough to get people talking before the announcement cycle gets crowded.”
Elias watched his fingers tremble against the counter.
“How many people would read it?”
Rebecca laughed. “That’s usually not the question authors ask.”
“How many?”
“If it catches? Tens of thousands. Maybe more.”
Sam’s face at the diner came back to him. So did Rebecca staring at the note she could no longer remember writing, and William’s Probably coincidence in the black notebook.
“Elias?”
“Not yet.”
For six days he stayed away from the manuscript. By the seventh, the stairs hurt again. On the eighth, he reread William’s notebook.
On the ninth, Rebecca emailed:
Offer stands. We can have it live Tuesday.
Elias began a reply.
No. Not yet.
He left the words on the screen while he walked around the block twice. When he came back, he stood in the kitchen without taking off his coat.
Sam’s last envelope was in a drawer beside the refrigerator.
Elias opened the drawer, looked at it, and closed the drawer again.
Then he returned to the laptop, deleted his reply, and typed:
Do it.
The preorder campaign went live Tuesday morning.
By noon, thousands of people had opened the first three chapters. That evening Elias ate an entire steak. Wednesday he woke before his alarm. Thursday he jogged.
When he saw his doctor at the end of the week, the numbers that had worried them a month earlier had returned to normal.
Sam had read everything and given him a little at a time. A handful of people at Bell & Wren had given him more. Thousands of readers had done more still.
Elias stopped looking for another explanation.
He never told Rebecca. He never told Mara.
Explaining it would have made him sound insane, and there was another problem: anyone who believed him would tell him to stop.
Whether a reader lost a second, a minute, or an hour, Elias had no way of knowing. Maybe the loss shortened a life. Maybe it took something less measurable. He knew only what happened to him, what had happened to William, and what had probably happened to Sam.
Probably.
That word did a great deal of work.
The three-chapter preview had been opened 413,000 times when Elias found a sentence at the bottom of page 217 that had not been there the night before.
He read it twice.
Its presence was impossible, but the sentence itself disturbed him more. It belonged there. The rhythm and turn of the scene seemed to have been waiting for it. Even the word Elias would normally have changed on instinct was the word the paragraph needed.
He checked the document history. No edit. No tracked change.
Elias deleted the sentence and closed the file.
The next morning it was back, with another beneath it.
He stared at the two sentences, closed the document, and went about his day. By then the preview count had climbed another several thousand.
When he returned the following morning, there were six paragraphs.
Elias left them alone.
He read:
She had believed a debt was a simple thing: a name written down, an amount beside it, a day when the owing might end.
But some debts survived the people who made them.
Some passed quietly from hand to hand until no one remembered who had borrowed and who had paid.
By the time she understood what had been taken from her, everyone who might have returned it was dead.
William had not written it. Elias had not written it.
Relief came before fear.
The publisher wanted another excerpt.
Elias said yes.
They chose a passage from one of the sections that had appeared without him:
Her father had been dead nine years before she noticed he had stopped appearing in her dreams.
The loss frightened her more than the dreams ever had.
For months afterward she slept badly, afraid that forgetting him had finally become something she was doing on purpose.
Preorders doubled.
Elias closed the manuscript that night. When he opened it the following morning, there was another page.
Soon he was checking before coffee. Sometimes nothing had changed. Sometimes there was a sentence. After a large interview about William’s final book, two pages appeared overnight.
He gradually wrote less of it himself.
He kept feeding it because he needed to know what happened next.
By January, people were commenting on how good Elias looked. Mara said grief must have agreed with him, then apologized so quickly that Elias laughed. He had lost twelve pounds. Some of the gray at his temples had receded. A pair of glasses he had worn for six years now gave him headaches, and his optometrist told him his prescription had improved.
“That happens sometimes,” she said.
Elias nodded. He had become very fond of the phrase sometimes.
Rebecca’s deterioration was subtle enough that anyone who saw her only occasionally might have missed it. Elias didn’t. She rubbed her eyes throughout their calls, and once she asked him a question they had discussed the day before.
He answered it again.
She thanked him.
Past Due was scheduled for publication in April, but the manuscript remained unfinished. Only fourteen pages seemed to be missing. The story had narrowed toward something inevitable, like hearing a chord and knowing another must follow.
Then nothing appeared.
A week passed.
Elias wrote three pages himself and spent two days in bed afterward. Rebecca read them. His strength improved a little, but the manuscript remained unchanged.
Bell & Wren released another promotional chapter.
That evening Elias closed the document without touching the unfinished page.
He woke feeling twenty years younger.
Four new pages were waiting.
The night before Bell & Wren planned to open international preorders, Elias sat alone in his university office.
Student manuscripts were stacked on the shelf. The same chipped coffee mug sat beside the monitor. A flyer for the fall faculty reading had been pinned to the corkboard so long that one corner had curled inward.
He remembered telling students in this room that publication wasn’t the point, that writing mattered even when nobody read it.
He wondered whether he had ever believed that.
Rebecca called at 9:17 p.m.
“We can delay,” she said.
The final page on Elias’s screen ended halfway down.
“What happens if we delay?”
“We lose momentum.”
“That’s all?”
“That’s not nothing.”
“No,” Elias said. “It isn’t.”
Rebecca waited.
“What if we wait?” he asked.
“For what?”
“I don’t know.”
“You want my opinion?”
“No.”
“That’s never stopped me before.”
Elias smiled.
“If you want to wait, we wait,” Rebecca said. “I mean it.”
His hands didn’t hurt. His legs were steady. Only the blank space beneath the last sentence remained.
Rebecca said his name.
Elias kept looking at the page.
“Open the preorders.”
She exhaled softly. “All right.”
Before leaving the office, Elias closed the manuscript.
He slept badly.
When he woke, Bell & Wren’s international preorder page was live, and readers overseas were already opening the three-chapter preview.
Elias opened the manuscript.
It was complete.
Still wearing the clothes from the night before, he sat at his desk and read the final pages slowly. They were better than anything William had written, better than anything Elias had written, though by then better felt like a word intended for lesser things.
The sentences had grown longer than William’s tended to be. They moved patiently, almost without regard for him, as though they knew exactly where they were going. Elias found himself slowing to match them.
The kitchen scene had returned.
He had forgotten how long it had been since he thought about that first unfinished question.
How long do you think a person can owe something before it stops being a debt?
The other character answered:
“It doesn’t stop being a debt,” she said. “You just stop being the one who has to pay it.”
Elias read the sentence twice.
He breathed easier than he had since Mara brought him the box.
His hand moved toward the phone on the desk. Rebecca’s name was near the top of his recent calls. He rested his thumb above it, imagining the conversation long enough to know he would never have it.
Then he turned the phone facedown.
At 10:14 a.m., Rebecca emailed.
International preorder page is live. Early preview numbers are excellent.
William had asked him not to let the story disappear. Elias had done better than that. Every international preorder came with the first three chapters, and before noon readers in six countries had already opened them. By 12:30 there were more. The preorder numbers rose quietly on the screen, each one appearing and becoming part of the total before the next arrived.
Elias went back to the last page.
There was another paragraph.
Discover more from Darling Nightmares
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.